Min Rent
Max Rent
Bedrooms
Search Area
Sorting
Pet Friendly Options
Rental Features
2. Baybreeze I
3. Countryside
4. Flowerfield
5. Eastender
6. Driftwood
7. The Ardsley - Lower and Upper
8. The Briarcliff - Lower & Upper
Please wait while we fetch your results
Cities Near Shelter Island
Westmoreland, NY (2.3mi)
Greenport, NY (4.1mi)
Sag Harbor, NY (4.5mi)
East Marion, NY (5.0mi)
Southold, NY (5.4mi)
Orient, NY (6.1mi)
Peconic, NY (7.5mi)
Cutchogue, NY (8.8mi)
East Hampton, NY (9.7mi)
Southampton, NY (12.5mi)
Laurel, NY (13.2mi)
Hampton Bays, NY (16.0mi)
Old Saybrook, CT (16.9mi)
Old Lyme, CT (17.8mi)
Westbrook, CT (18.3mi)
Clinton, CT (18.6mi)
East Quogue, NY (19.4mi)
Montauk, NY (19.6mi)
Zip Codes in Shelter Island, New York
Shelter Island, NY Apartments for Rent
MyApartmentMap is not a classifieds site, but an apartment listing/locator guide. With thousands of apartment listings in Shelter Island, NY, including apartment buildings, complexes and communities, duplexes, single family homes and houses; you are sure to find an affordable and cheap lease at a price that meets your budget.
Apartment hunting with MyApartmentMap makes finding rental deals in the Shelter Island, New York area easier than ever. When using MyApartmentMap's apartment rental listing service, you have the ability to sort by price, bedrooms, search area and distance from your specified city. By using our map below each of our listings, you also have the ability to find rentals near specific Shelter Island locations; such as laundry facilities, restaurants and schools and gyms. While we currently do not list apartment reviews and ratings for rentals, we plan on adding this feature in the near future.
Many of the results on this page are 
